Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

according to people

152
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #209,006 most helpful out of 571,544,897 reviews
★☆☆☆☆
Search Feature is totally unacceptable
We recently picked up this product for Christmas and are thoroughly disappointed with it. This appears to be just a JPEG scan of every single page from the various issues, advertisements and all, and no actual "text" (the text of the articles are scanned; they didn't bother using OCR to convert it to ASCII text). The collection spans 6 DVDs only because everything is an image; the low image quality certainly doesn't need 6 DVDs and ASCII text also would not. The scanned text is also why the search feature is completely worthless: there's no text to actually search. Instead, you're simply searching a tiny subset of terms that someone decided were relevant to each article. If you were expecting to be able to do a full-text search over 120 years, as I was, you will be sorely disappointed. With this volume of articles and data, a comprehensive, full-text search feature is an absolute must. That this feature is missing makes this product totally unusable. Having everything be a low-quality JPEG image also means that you cannot copy and paste any quotes if you are using an article as a reference in a paper. In short, this is an interesting idea that went horribly wrong during implementation.
December 2010 · Electronics
the product in question
The Complete National Geographic - Every Issue since 1888
3.8★ · 167 ratings, as of 2023
← worser → bester