Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I have been wearing this mascara for at least 2 years...it's my absolute favourite because it stays on all day, my lashes curl nicely, and doesn't clump when I put it on. That being said, I just re-ordered it from this seller and it's a complete disaster. First, the brush is different. It is shorter and thicker than the previous one I bought just back in November. (See my pictures - The top picture is the new tube and the bottom one is the previous one.) The mascara itself is gross. It's really super thick, clumps when I put it on, and when I screw the top back on a bunch of it oozes out all over the bottle. Either the manufacturer has changed it's formulation and brush, or this seller is not selling the right product. I'm going to return this and hope to find it with another seller where the product is the same as it's been for the years I've been using it!