Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I purchased this pot wanting to make broths in it. First time, I used it to make beef broth with bones. When I drained it, I noticed there was pitting all over the bottom of the pot. (like the top layer had been peeled off.) After one use, this was unacceptable. I contacted Amazon and even though it was outside the return window, they sent me a new one. Today I made chicken broth in the new pot, even though I was leery of it... Well, guess what. After one use, AGAIN, I have pitting on the bottom of the pot. I will be asking for a refund from Amazon, but in the mean time, I'm trying to decide if I have to throw out this huge batch of broth again. I have never been so disappointed with an Amazon purchase. I honestly don't understand how a pot made these days can be such terrible quality. And two of them in a row? I don't know how that could have been by chance. I can only assume a lot of these pots are that way.