141
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #215,826 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★☆☆☆
Too many likenesses to Twilight
Granted I'm no author, so this review won't win any Pulitzers. In fact, I had to double-check that I spelled "Pulitzer" correctly.
I admit it freely, I read Twilight. I enjoyed it for what it was; a light, easy read which took me back a decade...okay TWO...to my teenage years. Stephenie Meyer got a lot of flack about her abilities as a writer, but she never claimed to be a Poet Laureate and while the literary elite of the world snicker at her "little books" she's laughing all the way to the bank.
I can't help but feel this author is trying too hard for Meyers-like fame. I caught glimpses of reviews that warned me this was much along the same lines as the Twilight series only the "love" shared by the main characters is not so chaste. I was prepared for some easy-reading and a little bit of a plot. But what I found just leaves me, well, annoyed. Disclaimer: I'm only about 80% finished with the first book, I'm not even sure if the others are out yet?
I was NOT prepared for the striking similarities that I found between the two book series. If you're like me and cannot help but dwell on things once you notice them, I warn you - READ NO FURTHER if you're planning on reading these, it'll ruin them for you as it did me.
I know it seems SUPER PICKY, but these are just the main things that stood out glaringly. I'm not even mentioning the little subtleties in the writing or plot (ahem, going down south to see her mother and boyfriend has to come along). Anyway, here's my list:
TWILIGHT
Edward
Height: Tall
Body: Well Built
Hair: Copper, messy
Wallet: Rich
Family: Adopted
Personality: Brooding, Secretive
Other Attributes:
*Repeatedly tells Bella to stay away 'cos he's bad news
*Buys Bella a car which pisses her off
*Wants to drink Bella's blood
...SHADES OF GREY
Christian
Height: Check
Body: Check
Wallet: Check
Family: Check
Personality: Check
*Ditto with Ana
*Ditto with Ana
*Wants to spill Ana's blood, or at least mark her up a bit
And now our heroines
Bella
Body: Slender
Hair: Long brown hair
Wallet: Middle-class, all-American girl
Family: Hair-brained Mom, trust-worty dad
BFF: A dark-skinned guy pines for her, she just wants to be friends
Vehicle: A rusty old beater that she loves
Other Attributes:
*Thinks she's average looking, but is pretty
*Clumsy
*Insecure about herself
*Virgin
Anastasia
Body: Check
Hair: Check
Wallet: Check
Family: Check
BFF: Check
Vehicle: Check
Other Attributes:
*Check
*Check
*Check
*Check
I rest my case. Yet I'm still reading it. If I sit too long wondering what that says about me I may need a therapist.
March 2012 · Books · verified purchase