Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I have seen the picture of this model pop up in ads on my computer for probably a year. I finally started researching buying this cardigan. There seems to be multiple cardigans made from different material and sold by different vendors, who all use this same picture. I first came across a different vendor selling this "same" cardigan and the reviews were pretty bad. Mostly saying it was not cotton at all (said to be cotton blend), clingy and poorly made. So I kept searching amazon to see what other cardigans might work. Then I found this vendor. TOTALLY different cardigan than the first one I found, even though it is the same picture. It had great reviews except one saying it runs small, which it does. But OMG how I love this cardigan. I got one in the darker blue color. It is beautiful! it hits my hip a little shorter than what is shown on the model, but I honestly wouldn't want it any longer. This one IS a cotton blend and though I have only washed it once, it seems to wash well. I am 5'4" and weigh about 140 with an athletic build, I am between a small and a medium. I got a medium per the reviews and it is perfect. This is a thin cardigan, so wearing it over shirts that have any bulk or details would show through. I am about to order 3 more on orange, grey and burgundy. Happy shopping!