Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

Not sure if you've noticed but you can't find these in the drug stores anymore. The new ones are weird. They go on way too dark, are not smooth to apply and the smudge thingy is rubber instead of spongy like this one. Oh and most of them are like a twistable crayon which I did not find to be a plus. This is the good old one you've used for years so if you're unhappy with the eyeliner pencils you're finding in the stores now, you'll be happy to be back with this one. Don't know why they tried to change it. It didn't need any improvement. Color was as expected and it applies wonderfully and lasts all day. This is definitely one of those things where "Don't fix it if it ain't broke" applies.