Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

So these are a gift for my mama. Size 10 ½ They are one and half sizes too big for me but I wanted to post and hope the pictures help. Positives: The inside has a nice felt lining. Not thin or thick. But good. The bottoms have a soft rubber on them with good grip. The boot has good cushion when walking. Cute! Cute! cute!. Wow I'm surprised how adorable they truly are! I got the gray/white6 I was able to get these $15. Yes worth it! Even at $30 I say yes! I was unsure about the colors but nope they're great. Cons: The bottom (the part that covers the top of foot/toes) is sort like targets winter boots. It's not a hard rubber. Feels like a fake leather. I could push my finger nail into it and it would show. My target boots didn't last 2 years and started cracking. I don't know if these will do that. I hope not for the price I think their worth finding out. Not sure about deep snow with having the side zipper. Also doubt these are truly waterproof. I'll see what my mom thinks but think I'm ordering a pair for myself. These boots are I can see being good for shoveling snow, walking to school in winter, shopping, looking cute in winter. A few weeks ago I ordered the Columbia ice maiden II. In 9 ½... When I put those boots on… I feel like I'm putting something on that works good but I find really unattractive. Comparing them side by side. Update: my mom loved them. I ordered a 9 for myself.