Bests & Worsts Reviews from Amazon

I'm HORRIBLE at applying eyeliner, so this was a godsend. It's creamy, so it doesn't snag on your eyelid when you apply it, but it dries out in a minute or so, so it actually lasts all day. If I want a darker look, I put on black or navy eyeliner and then apply this on top -- it smooths over the shakiness of the dark eyeliner, and looks a whole lot more interesting (like I actually put work into it, when I really didn't). I also wear it by itself sometimes, because it's light and looks a bit like metallic eyeshadow if you smudge it -- but still appropriate for wearing to class or going to work. I used to use Glossier's Lidstar (liquid eye shadow), but I found this and it works so much better -- it stays on for a lot longer, doesn't fade, and actually reaches the lid line. Even though it stays on for a while (all day -- 10 hours +), it comes off really easily with a wipe or miscellar water. It's great for covering mistakes or simply as a stand-in so you don't have to project to the world that you have no clue what you're doing with eyeliner. I plan to buy the gold/blue too. (Note: you can find this product for a lot cheaper at any other store -- Bed, Bath + Beyond/Target/CVS/Ulta.)