429
people found this helpful, as of 2023
ranked #47,111 most helpful
out of 571,544,897 reviews
★★★★☆
Dear Amazon,
This is one of the best versions of the trilogy you're going to find, hands down. Perfect aspect ratio, 1080p HD resolution, hours of quality extra content, etc.
That said, I did not receive the box set that was pictured. I got what I wanted for a good price, but the box and it's contents (aside from the discs of course) were not what was advertised. This is a recurring problem with this website. When you have films on your website that come in many different versions and editions, you need to separate them into different product pages entirely, with detailed, specific descriptions of each unique version with pictures included so that your customers know exactly what they're purchasing, and the product reviews must be separated accordingly too. Instead you've got every available version of this box set lumped into a single product page in a vague, disorganized mess. The product images tell us virtually nothing because they all use the same generic pictures; the cover of ONE of the MANY different versions of the set followed by screenshots from the films, which are about as useful to us as a picture of oxygen to a drowning man. On top of that, instead of letting us review the specific version of the product we received, you group all of the reviews together as if we all received the same product, which we definitely did not, forcing US to be unnecessarily detailed in our reviews in order to help others discern which version of the set we are describing. FIX THIS. The fact that this is still a problem after such a long time is absurd, no wonder you have so many people confused and unhappy because they didn't receive what they expected.
October 2020 · Movies and TV · verified purchase